Murray C. Morgan
Since 1892, rapid transit plans have been up in the air
The News Tribune
September 7, 1995
P. FP15

Northwest Room & Special Collections
Murray's People: A collection of essays

Since 1892, Rapid Transit Plans Have Been Up in the Air

spacerThe first proposal for a rapid transit system connecting Puget Sound communities was made more than a century ago.
spacerIn the summer of 1892 Lucien F. Cook, a Tacoma real estate dealer and inventor, set up a miniature working model of an elevated, electric-powered railroad. He invited visitors and especially investors to see the big toy in the Tacoma Post Office building at 1016 Pacific Ave.
spacerCook's contraption had two narrow tracks, one above the other, suspended from poles on a single line of piers. The car was designed to be suspended from the upper track and stabilized by horizontal wheels at the bottom of the car, bearing against the lower rail. The car would be very light and extremely narrow, only three feet wide with passengers in single file, one behind the other.
spacerCars would be constructed in varied length to seat from eight to 30 riders. Cook estimated that it would cost about $15,000 a mile to construct a track from Tacoma's Commencement Bay to Seattle's Elliott Bay, and that the trip would take 20 minutes.
spacerCook found enough support to be able to build a full-sized model, about a quarter-mile long, on the waterfront below the Tacoma Hotel, which stood on A Street Between 10th and 11th.
spacerTest runs were conducted on the afternoon of Friday, Nov. 26. The first runs were made with an empty car. Those runs went so well that as many as 10 volunteers at a time risked the trip in the flimsy cars. There was no regulator to adjust the flow of power so the train's starts and stops were emphatically abrupt, but no one was hurt.
spacerCivil engineer Henry Shaw, who served as motorman, said he would not be afraid to run a train at 100 miles an hour. Promoter Cook thought the upper limit would be 200 mph and spoke of the possibility of a transcontinental train that would deliver the New York morning papers to Tacoma at 1 p.m.
spacerBut the Panic of '93 struck a few months later. Investment capital disappeared, as did all mention in the papers of Lucien Cook and the overhead rapid transit system.
spacerIn July of 1895 the Tacoma Daily Ledger carried a one-paragraph item on page 2 that said Henry Bucey of Buena was visiting town to raise funds for "an air line steam railroad" to run between Tacoma and Seattle. The subject never again came up in print.
spacerIn 1900 a conventional light rail service between Tacoma and Seattle began with electric engines drawing power from a third rail. It lasted more than 30 years before giving way to the automobile and the bus.
spacerBut even with the Interurban offering 70-minute trips between the two cities there were still those who dreamed of faster transportation, among them William H. Boyes.
spacerIn 1910 Boyes and two other men, all residents in a First Avenue hotel in Seattle, signed papers incorporating the Seattle-Tacoma Monorail Co., which proposed to offer high-speed rail service between Puget Sound cities.
spacerThey circulated a photo, supposedly taken somewhere on the Tacoma Tideflats, showing a futuristic car, remarkably like the present Seattle monorail cars.
spacerIt appears to be perhaps 25 feet long. Men in business clothes peer from the side windows. An engineer in hat, tie and vest sits in the drivers seat. The car rests on a single rail supported by a dozen closely spaced pillars. To one of the pillars two large signs are fastened. "Wm. H. Boyes," says one. "Monorail" says the other.
spacerNo contemporary story has been found in any Tacoma paper about the construction of the model. But in the spring of 1911 a man representing himself as G.E. Boyes, president of Boyes Monorail Edmonds Co. obtained a 25-year franchise from the Edmonds City Council to provide 10-minute monorail service between Edmonds and Seattle at 10 cents a ride.
spacerAccording to Kay V. Cloud's "Edmonds, The Gem of Puget Sound," the town held a civic celebration on May 2, 1911, when the first support post for the monorail was put in place. "Hopeful speeches were made."
spacerA week later, a "penetrating odor" emanating from the monorail site was traced to a dead skunk that had fallen into an open post hole. The skunk's demise was an ill omen. The timbers and steel for the monorail track and the experimental cars that were supposed to arrive within days never showed up.
spacerOn Oct. 21 of 1911 Harry Habey, J.L. Larimer and Royal A. McClure procured an order from a Judge Tallman requiring the Pacific Railway Co. (monorail) and W.H. Boyes, president, to show cause why a receiver should not be appointed. Boyes was ordered to allow stockholders to inspect the company books or show cause for his refusal. The stockholders charged that $15,000 worth of stock had been sold and that $10,000 had been used by Boyes for his personal requirements. It is not known if anyone got money back.
spacerNot until Seattle's Century 21 Exposition in 1962 was a working monorail built. The Alweg Rapid Transit Systems built a $3.5 million line to carry cars designed by an Italian automobile-building firm and manufactured in Germany.
spacerThe line runs from the downtown business district to the former exposition grounds, now the Seattle Center. There was talk of extending it to Boeing's Duwamish plant, or even running it to Tacoma.
spacerThat didn't happen, but the monorail still serves an estimated 400,000 passengers a year, gliding quietly over the street traffic.

# # #